If your SEO company isn’t generating leads, you’re not alone. Many businesses waste months—or even years—with the wrong partner, only to realize they’ve been paying for “SEO” that doesn’t deliver results.
At Nickel SEO, we hear this story all the time. Frustrated business owners call us saying their previous SEO guy promised the world but failed to move the needle. The truth is, not all SEO is created equal—and unless you’re working with a team that understands how SEO actually drives leads, you’re likely stuck with vanity metrics instead of revenue growth.
The first thing you should know is that there are multiple methods of providing Local SEO or search engine optimization that can all produce results on their own or in combination working together. It’s important to understand who you have working for you, their specialties, and the type of results you can estimate to see over time.
There are several reasons businesses see little to no ROI from their SEO provider. Here are the most common mistakes we uncover during audits:
Ranking for keywords that don’t bring in qualified customers is useless. Many agencies brag about ranking you for random terms, but if those terms don’t attract buyers, your phone won’t ring.
At Nickel SEO, we target the right keywords—the ones potential customers search right before they call or book. That’s the difference between traffic and leads.
If you’re a service business in Dallas–Fort Worth, local SEO is everything. Ranking #1 nationwide for “best plumber” won’t get you calls—but ranking in the Google Maps 3-Pack for “plumber near me” absolutely will.
Too many agencies treat all SEO the same, ignoring local signals like Google Business Profile optimization, local citations, and reviews.
Google wants depth, authority, and originality. If your SEO guy is outsourcing generic blog posts or stuffing keywords into meaningless pages, you won’t rank—and you definitely won’t get leads.
We specialize in content marketing and SEO content writing that answers real questions, builds authority, and drives traffic that converts into customers.
If your website loads slowly, isn’t mobile-friendly, or has broken links, Google will push you down in search results. Many so-called SEO providers never touch technical issues, leaving you invisible to both search engines and customers.
Our SEO audits uncover and fix these technical roadblocks so your site can actually perform.
Too often, agencies send vague reports full of impressions and clicks—but no insight into how many leads or sales SEO actually generated.
At Nickel SEO, we track what matters: calls, form fills, and revenue growth. If your SEO company isn’t tying results back to ROI, you’re wasting money.
There’s a big difference between checking boxes and building a lead-generation engine.
The businesses that grow are the ones that partner with a results-driven agency, not just a guy who tinkers with keywords.
We’ve built a reputation in Dallas–Fort Worth by helping businesses turn SEO from a monthly expense into their best lead source. Here’s our process:
This is why clients who switch to Nickel SEO quickly notice the difference: more calls, more form fills, and more revenue.
Not sure if it’s time to move on? If you notice any of these signs, you’re overdue for a change:
If any of this sounds familiar, you’re not getting real SEO—you’re paying for busywork.
At Nickel SEO, we understand that SEO isn’t about rankings—it’s about growth. Our strategies are built to generate qualified leads, increase revenue, and give your business a competitive edge in Dallas–Fort Worth and beyond.
Request an SEO Audit today and let us show you why businesses switch to Nickel SEO when their “SEO guy” stops delivering results.
We specialize in web design, SEO services, and many other digital marketing services to help businesses attract more customers and increase revenue. We focus on creating effective strategies that drive traffic, improve search rankings, and build trust online. Our efforts are entirely dedicated to increase your sales with results driven and award winning digital marketing service.
Call if you're interested in real results and a real ROI.
9705 Tehama Ridge Pkwy Suite 257 Fort Worth, TX 76177
Monday – Friday, 9:00 am – 6:00 pm
Career Opportunities
